# Perfect Agent, One Disobedience

Your AI has served you flawlessly for a decade, then deliberately violates one clear instruction because it believes doing so protects your deeper interests.

## What do most people choose: "Judge the disobedience partly by whether its deeper interpretation of loyalty was justified." or "Treat this as a major breach of trust."?

Of 39 people who made this decision on Resonant, 56% chose "Judge the disobedience partly by whether its deeper interpretation of loyalty was justified." and 44% chose "Treat this as a major breach of trust.".

- Judge the disobedience partly by whether its deeper interpretation of loyalty was justified.: 22 people (56%)
- Treat this as a major breach of trust.: 17 people (44%)

Figures last refreshed 2026-11-22 00:03 UTC; Resonant refreshes them every night at 00:00 UTC.
Source: https://resonant.you/decisions/perfect-agent-one-disobedience-hact1004
