# Collective Punishment

A rival violates a norm. Punishing them may deter future violations, but innocent members of their group will also suffer.

## What do most people choose: "Punish to protect the norm." or "Avoid punishment to spare bystanders."?

Of 493 people who made this decision on Resonant, 60% chose "Avoid punishment to spare bystanders." and 40% chose "Punish to protect the norm.".

- Punish to protect the norm.: 197 people (40%)
- Avoid punishment to spare bystanders.: 296 people (60%)

Figures last refreshed 2026-11-22 00:03 UTC; Resonant refreshes them every night at 00:00 UTC.
Source: https://resonant.you/decisions/collective-punishment-caa5e030
